If you're relocating to the Pittsburgh area, one of the biggest decisions you'll make is where to live. Two of the most desirable communities north of the city are Wexford and Sewickley. While they're only about 15 minutes apart, they offer distinctly different lifestyles.
As a Realtor specializing in Pittsburgh's northern suburbs, I often help buyers compare these two areas. The "right" choice depends on your priorities, whether that's top-rated schools, a walkable downtown, newer homes, or a shorter commute.
Let's take a closer look.
Schools
For many buyers, schools are the deciding factor.
Wexford is a ZIP code (15090), not a municipality. Most homes people think of as "Wexford" are located in North Allegheny School District, although some neighborhoods are served by Pine-Richland School District. North Allegheny is consistently ranked among the top public school districts in Pennsylvania and is a major draw for buyers relocating to the area.
Sewickley is served primarily by Quaker Valley School District, another highly regarded district known for strong academics, smaller enrollment, and a close-knit community feel.
Both school districts have excellent reputations, so the choice often comes down to the type of community you're looking for.
Housing
One of the biggest differences between the two areas is the style and age of the homes.
In Wexford, you'll find:
- Newer subdivisions
- Executive neighborhoods
- Luxury communities
- Maintenance-free patio homes and townhomes
- New construction opportunities
- Homes on larger suburban lots
The area appeals to buyers looking for modern floor plans, open kitchens, three-car garages, and newer amenities.
Sewickley offers a very different housing mix.
You'll find:
- Historic homes with architectural character
- Charming cottages
- Beautiful brick Colonials
- Luxury estates
- Homes within walking distance of the village
- Riverfront next to train tracks and hillside properties
Many homes date back decades—or even more than a century—giving Sewickley a timeless charm that's difficult to replicate.
Commute
Both communities offer convenient access to Downtown Pittsburgh and Pittsburgh International Airport, but there are differences.
From Wexford, commuters benefit from quick access to I-79 and I-279, making travel to Downtown, Cranberry Township, Robinson, and the airport relatively straightforward.
Sewickley offers excellent access to the airport and major employment centers in Robinson and Moon Township. Downtown Pittsburgh is also an easy drive, although travel times can vary depending on bridge traffic.
Restaurants and Shopping
If you enjoy dining out, both communities have plenty to offer.
Wexford has become a regional destination for shopping and restaurants. Along Route 19, you'll find everything from locally owned restaurants and coffee shops to national retailers, grocery stores, fitness centers, and everyday conveniences.
Sewickley Village offers a completely different experience. The walkable downtown is filled with locally owned boutiques, cafés, bakeries, wine bars, and restaurants. Many residents enjoy spending an afternoon strolling the village, grabbing coffee, browsing shops, or dining outdoors.
If you love small-town charm, Sewickley is hard to beat.
Luxury Homes
Both communities have outstanding luxury homes, but they appeal to different buyers.
Luxury homes in Wexford often feature:
- Newer construction
- Large open floor plans
- Finished lower levels
- Outdoor living spaces
- Pools
- Smart home technology
- Three- and four-car garages
Luxury buyers who prefer newer homes with modern amenities are often drawn to Wexford.
In Sewickley, luxury homes frequently emphasize:
- Historic architecture
- Custom craftsmanship
- Mature landscaping
- Estate-sized lots
- Privacy
- Timeless elegance
The Sewickley area also includes some of the Pittsburgh region's most prestigious estate neighborhoods, where homes sit on several acres and offer exceptional privacy.
Walkability
This may be the biggest difference between the two communities.
Sewickley Village is one of the most walkable communities in the Pittsburgh area. Many residents can walk to restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, parks, and community events. It offers a true small-town atmosphere that's increasingly difficult to find.
Wexford is much more car-oriented. While some neighborhoods have sidewalks and nearby parks, most errands require driving. In exchange, residents enjoy newer developments, larger lots, and convenient access to shopping and major highways.
Which Community Is Right for You?
Choose Wexford if you want:
- Highly rated schools
- Newer homes
- Modern floor plans
- Luxury neighborhoods
- Convenient shopping
- Easy highway access
Choose Sewickley if you want:
- A walkable downtown
- Historic charm
- Boutique shopping
- Character-filled homes
- A close-knit community
- Timeless architecture
My Perspective as a Local Realtor
One of the things I love most about helping relocation buyers is matching them with the community that truly fits their lifestyle.
Some buyers immediately fall in love with the energy and convenience of Wexford. Others know the moment they stroll through Sewickley Village that they've found home.
The good news is there's no wrong choice. Both communities offer exceptional quality of life, beautiful homes, and strong long-term appeal. The key is finding the one that best matches your priorities.
If you're considering a move to the Pittsburgh area, I'd be happy to help you compare neighborhoods, tour homes, and explore the communities that fit your lifestyle best.
